Experimenting with supports

 I need some tiny parts - cylinders 2.4 mm across, 2 mm high, with a hole in the middle. They need to be pretty accurate - bogies will rotate on them and a "top hat" pin needs to go through the hole. What is the best way to support them for printing?

Small parts need a relatively large number of supports - I have already established that - but that has a necessary loos of fidelity. My first attempt had them vertical, with three medium supports directly under it. Out of eight prints, two were useable - the rest the holes did not form, and the bases were rough on all of them, though sanding did resolve that.

So here are six trials.


On the left, three using light supports, on the right medium supports. In the top row three supports directly under the part, in the middle row I have the supports out at the sides; this allows space for more light supports - I am pretty sure three medium is enough. On the bottom row, I have tried having the cylinder horizontal.

I did three of each, as there can be some variation. It was not a warm day (outside temperate ca. 8°C), and that will have influenced the results. Nevertheless, I was surprised to find all adhered to the plate.

Top right had the least definition at the bottom, which is what I was looking to avoid. None of them had holes that went all the way through, but I was able to drill through with a pin drill for most. In that regard, middle right was best as I could drill through with the supports in place (middle left the supports started to snap during drilling).

Overall, a bit inconclusive, but I will be happier just doing three light supports as a minimum for small parts in the future.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Various tank wagons

Image
I am a chemist by profession, and so the transport of chemicals by rail is of interest. In fact I wrote an article on the topic, see here . Nitrogen Liquors The appeal for these is in the name, which makes no sense at all if you are a chemist. They actually contained ammonium nitrate, which is a fertiliser used to put nitrogen in soil, which will be where the name comes from, presumably a solution in water, that is likely both hot - given the wagons are lagged - and very concentrated. Images of the prototype can he found here . They are so dirty it is not possible to tell the original colour, but I am guessing green? One end has four flanges; these would have been to allow the contents to be heated using steam. They were printed separately. The wagons have channels down the sides to catch spills. i guess this is to ensure the solution down not end up between the rails, where it could mix with oil to create an explosive mixture. The ladders are brass. The chasses are Peco. Carbon Dioxid
Read more

Introduction to the Blog

 My first post was back in February - before I had even purchased a 3d printer, and it is now November and I am writing the introduction... This blog is all about my experiences for 3d printing. It is a way for me to share what I learn along the way, and to show off what I have created. Most pages are tagged Model and are about a specific model, and the prototype it is based on. Generally I try to visit the prototype, and include a couple of photos of that for comparison. I also try to learn the history of the building, which is not always easy, and record that on the page too. A lot are buildings in and around Preston, as that is where I live. Models are further divided into Building , Railway (i.e., railway-related buildings), Feature (bridges, tunnel portals, etc.), Rolling Stock and Clutter (smaller items) In addition, there are pages tagged How to and Prototype . If you want to know how to use Blender to make 3d models, there is an article I wrote on another site.
Read more

Preston City Mission

Image
This is a delightful building on Corporation Street, as it meets the Ring Road, and I guess in the only wooden building left in Preston. I miscalculated the scale, and this is it at 1/420 scale (approximately T gauge), and just 5 cm long. The prototype was built in 1900 as the Railway Mission. Previously services had been held on the station platform allowing railway workers obliged to work on Sunday to worship. Some time around 1980 British Rail decided to sell the land, and it looked like it would go to a property developer, but the church raised funds to buy the plot , and it became Preston Evangelical Mission, and at some point later Preston City Mission (when Preston became a city in 2002?). It seems to have survived at least two further plans to redevelop the area, in ca 2009 and 2019. There is an photo here of it from before the Ring Road was built here . This one, in colour, from ca. 1970 here  must be after the Ring Road was built, but with a building to the left still standi
Read more